Supreme Court decisions on dismissal cases of school personnel: their implications to educational administration / (Record no. 27698)

000 -LEADER
fixed length control field 13156nam a2201237Ia 4500
000 - LEADER
fixed length control field 10995ntm a2200205 i 4500
001 - CONTROL NUMBER
control field 69147
003 - CONTROL NUMBER IDENTIFIER
control field 0
005 - DATE AND TIME OF LATEST TRANSACTION
control field 20250920174315.0
008 - FIXED-LENGTH DATA ELEMENTS--GENERAL INFORMATION
fixed length control field 171111n 000 0 eng d
010 ## - LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CONTROL NUMBER
Canceled/invalid LC control number
--
--
LC control number
NUCMC control number
015 ## - NATIONAL BIBLIOGRAPHY NUMBER
Source 2
National bibliography number
016 ## - NATIONAL BIBLIOGRAPHIC AGENCY CONTROL NUMBER
Source
--
Record control number
Canceled/invalid control number
020 ## - INTERNATIONAL STANDARD BOOK NUMBER
--
--
International Standard Book Number
--
Canceled/invalid ISBN
Terms of availability
Qualifying information
--
022 ## - INTERNATIONAL STANDARD SERIAL NUMBER
Incorrect ISSN
--
ISSN-L
International Standard Serial Number 2
024 ## - OTHER STANDARD IDENTIFIER
Source of number or code
--
Additional codes following the standard number or code
Terms of availability
Standard number or code
Qualifying information
028 ## - PUBLISHER OR DISTRIBUTOR NUMBER
Publisher or distributor number
--
Source
029 ## - OTHER SYSTEM CONTROL NUMBER (OCLC)
OCLC library identifier
--
System control number
032 ## - POSTAL REGISTRATION NUMBER
Postal registration number
--
Source agency assigning number
035 ## - SYSTEM CONTROL NUMBER
System control number
--
--
Canceled/invalid control number
--
--
037 ## - SOURCE OF ACQUISITION
Note
--
Terms of availability
Stock number
Source of stock number/acquisition
040 ## - CATALOGING SOURCE
Description conventions
-- rda
Original cataloging agency
Modifying agency
Language of cataloging
Transcribing agency
041 ## - LANGUAGE CODE
Language code of librettos
--
Language code of text/sound track or separate title
Language code of summary or abstract
Language code of accompanying material other than librettos and transcripts
Language code of original
Language code of accessible visual language
043 ## - GEOGRAPHIC AREA CODE
Geographic area code
--
Local GAC code
045 ## - TIME PERIOD OF CONTENT
Formatted 9999 B.C. through C.E. time period
--
Time period code
050 ## - LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CALL NUMBER
Classification number
--
Supplementary class number (MU) [OBSOLETE]
Item number 2
-- 0
051 ## - LIBRARY OF CONGRESS COPY, ISSUE, OFFPRINT STATEMENT
Copy information
--
Classification number
Item number
055 ## - CLASSIFICATION NUMBERS ASSIGNED IN CANADA
Classification number
--
Item number
060 ## - NATIONAL LIBRARY OF MEDICINE CALL NUMBER
Classification number
--
Item number
070 ## - NATIONAL AGRICULTURAL LIBRARY CALL NUMBER
Classification number
--
Item number
072 ## - SUBJECT CATEGORY CODE
Source
--
--
Subject category code
Subject category code subdivision
082 ## - DEWEY DECIMAL CLASSIFICATION NUMBER
Classification number
--
--
Item number 2
--
084 ## - OTHER CLASSIFICATION NUMBER
Number source
--
Classification number
086 ## - GOVERNMENT DOCUMENT CLASSIFICATION NUMBER
Number source
--
Classification number
090 ## - LOCALLY ASSIGNED LC-TYPE CALL NUMBER (OCLC); LOCAL CALL NUMBER (RLIN)
Classification number (OCLC) (R) ; Classification number, CALL (RLIN) (NR)
--
--
Local cutter number (OCLC) ; Book number/undivided call number, CALL (RLIN)
--
092 ## - LOCALLY ASSIGNED DEWEY CALL NUMBER (OCLC)
Filing suffix
--
Classification number
Item number
096 ## - LOCALLY ASSIGNED NLM-TYPE CALL NUMBER (OCLC)
Classification number
--
Item number
097 ## -
--
--
--
100 ## - MAIN ENTRY--PERSONAL NAME
Relator term
--
Personal name Santiago, Ricardo Teodoro.
Dates associated with a name
Numeration 4
Affiliation
Titles and words associated with a name 0
Fuller form of name 16
110 ## - MAIN ENTRY--CORPORATE NAME
Relator term
--
Corporate name or jurisdiction name as entry element
Date of meeting or treaty signing
Subordinate unit
Number of part/section/meeting
Location of meeting
Form subheading
111 ## - MAIN ENTRY--MEETING NAME
Meeting name or jurisdiction name as entry element
--
Date of meeting or treaty signing
Number [OBSOLETE]
Number of part/section/meeting
Location of meeting
130 ## - MAIN ENTRY--UNIFORM TITLE
Version
--
Uniform title
Name of part/section of a work
Date of a work
Language of a work
Form subheading
210 ## - ABBREVIATED TITLE
Abbreviated title
--
Qualifying information
222 ## - KEY TITLE
Key title
--
Qualifying information
240 ## - UNIFORM TITLE
Version
--
Uniform title
Medium of performance for music
Miscellaneous information
Number of part/section of a work
Date of a work
Language of a work
Arranged statement for music
Name of part/section of a work
Form subheading
245 #0 - TITLE STATEMENT
Title
-- Supreme Court decisions on dismissal cases of school personnel: their implications to educational administration /
Designation of section section/part/series: (SE) [OBSOLETE]
Remainder of title
Number of part/section of a work
Statement of responsibility, etc. Ricardo Teodoro Santiago.
Medium 6
Name of part/section of a work
246 ## - VARYING FORM OF TITLE
Title proper/short title
--
Remainder of title
Number of part/section of a work
Display text
Date or sequential designation 6
Name of part/section of a work
249 ## -
--
--
--
250 ## - EDITION STATEMENT
Linkage
--
Edition statement
Remainder of edition statement
260 ## - PUBLICATION, DISTRIBUTION, ETC.
Place of manufacture
--
Place of publication, distribution, etc.
Name of publisher, distributor, etc.
Manufacturer
Date of publication, distribution, etc.
Date of manufacture
264 ## - PRODUCTION, PUBLICATION, DISTRIBUTION, MANUFACTURE, AND COPYRIGHT NOTICE
Materials specified
--
Place of production, publication, distribution, manufacture
--
Name of producer, publisher, distributor, manufacturer
Date of production, publication, distribution, manufacture, or copyright notice 46
300 ## - PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION
Accompanying material
--
Dimensions 28 cm.
Extent xxv, 143 pages
Other physical details
310 ## - CURRENT PUBLICATION FREQUENCY
Current publication frequency
--
Date of current publication frequency
321 ## - FORMER PUBLICATION FREQUENCY
Former publication frequency
--
Dates of former publication frequency
336 ## - CONTENT TYPE
Content type code
Content type term text
Source rdacontent
337 ## - MEDIA TYPE
Materials specified
-- 0
Media type code
Media type term unmediated
Source rdamedia
338 ## - CARRIER TYPE
Materials specified
-- 0
Carrier type code
Carrier type term volume
Source rdacarrier
340 ## - PHYSICAL MEDIUM
Source
-- 0
Color content
Font size
344 ## - SOUND CHARACTERISTICS
Source
--
Type of recording 0
Recording medium
347 ## - DIGITAL FILE CHARACTERISTICS
Source
--
File type 0
362 ## - DATES OF PUBLICATION AND/OR SEQUENTIAL DESIGNATION
Dates of publication and/or sequential designation
--
--
385 ## - AUDIENCE CHARACTERISTICS
Demographic group term
--
Audience term 2
410 ## - SERIES STATEMENT/ADDED ENTRY--CORPORATE NAME [OBSOLETE, CAN/MARC], [LOCAL, USA]
Title of a work
--
Subordinate unit
Corporate name or jurisdiction name as entry element
Volume number/sequential designation
440 ## - SERIES STATEMENT/ADDED ENTRY--TITLE
Name of part/section of a work
--
Title
International Standard Serial Number
Volume/sequential designation
490 ## - SERIES STATEMENT
Series statement
--
International Standard Serial Number
Volume/sequential designation
500 ## - GENERAL NOTE
General note
-- Thesis (M.A.) -- Pamantasan ng Lungsod ng Maynila, 1987.;A thesis presented to the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences and Education, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree in Master of Arts in Education Major in Educational Administration.
--
--
-- 56
504 ## - BIBLIOGRAPHY, ETC. NOTE
Bibliography, etc. note
--
--
505 ## - FORMATTED CONTENTS NOTE
Formatted contents note
--
--
Title
Miscellaneous information
Statement of responsibility
506 ## - RESTRICTIONS ON ACCESS NOTE
Terms governing access
-- 5
510 ## - CITATION/REFERENCES NOTE
Name of source
--
International Standard Serial Number
520 ## - SUMMARY, ETC.
Expansion of summary note
--
Assigning source
Summary, etc. ABSTRACT: STATEMENT OF THE PROBLEM: MAIN PROBLEM: This study analyzed the Supreme Court decisions on dismissal cases of school personnel, public and private, and their implications to educational administration. SUB PROBLEMS: 1. What is the distinction between tenure and dismissal as to: 1.1. source 1.2. subject 1.3. status 1.4. coverage 1.5. effect 2. What are the legal rights of the following school personnel during their probationary and tenure period? 2.1. public school personnel 2.2. private school personnel 3. What are the grounds for their dismissal? 4. What is the process of their dismissal? 5. How should their dismissal cases be contested? 6. How do school administrator decisions differ from the decisions of the: 6.1. Labor Arbiters? 6.2. Commissioners? 6.3. Judges? 6.4. Justices? B. What are the implications of the Supreme Court decisions on dismissal cases of school personnel to educational administration? PROCEDURE: The researcher made use of the descriptive survey method. Documentary analysis was used in gathering data for security of tenure and dismissal. The legal documents used are the 1986 Philippine Constitution, Labor Code of the Philippines, Education Act of 1982, the Civil Service Decree of the Philippine, Magna Carta for Public School Teachers and the Labor Code of the Philippines. With regard to implications of dismissal cases to educational administration, Volumes 1 to 143 of the Supreme Court Reports Annotated (SCRA) were reviewed as the decisions rendered by the school administrators, Labor Arbiters, Commissioners, Judges and Justices of the Supreme Court are embodied therein. The participants of this study were seventeen (17) petitioners and forty (40) respondents. TREATMENT OF DATA: The data gathered were recorded, tabulated and analyzed. As the variables were limited, statistical treatment did not warrant thus descriptive analysis. FINDINGS: On the basis of the data gathered, the study obtained the following findings: A.1 Distinction Between Tenure and Dismissal Tenure and dismissal are distinct from each other in source as tenure is bilateral acts of the employer and the employee, whereas, dismissal is a unilateral act of the employer in casting off the employees; in subject as tenure is awarded to deserving employees, whereas, dismissal is imposed against undeserving employees; in status as tenure is a valued mark of status. In fact, regular or permanent status is granted an employee after a trial period, whereas, dismissal is a blot on status. It is dislocation and disruption of the individual's life; in coverage as tenure is from the beginning of service after the execution of a contract and after probationary period, whereas dismissal is from the termination of service from the end of the contract or during tenure appointment; and in effect as tenure is continuous until retirement unless terminated by virtue of a valid just cause, whereas, dismissal is stoppage of employment; lay-off; discharge of an employee from his work. 2. Legal Rights of School Personnel During Their Probationary and Tenure Period The labor rights of public school personnel are governed by the Civil Service Law pursuant to P.D. No. 807 known as the Civil Service Decree of the Philippines, Article IV-Scope of the Civil Service. All such persons must serve a probationary period of six months following their original appointment and shall undergo a thorough character investigation in order to acquire permanent civil service status. Appointment in the career service shall be permanent or temporary, the latter shall not exceed twelve months. The Magna Carta for Public School Teachers, Section 4-Probationary Period stated in essence that no probationary period precedes regular appointment after an efficient, satisfactory service. The Constitutional guarantee of security of tenure applies not only to the regular employees but also to probationary employees as the latter can only be dismissed upon valid or just cause. 3. Grounds for Dismissal of School Personnel Section 36 of P.D. 807, enumerates the grounds for dismissal of public school personnel, to wit: (1) Dishonesty; (2) Oppression; (3) Neglect of Duty; (4) Misconduct; (5) Disgraceful and immoral conduct; (6) Being notoriously undesirable; (7) Discourtesy in the course of official duties; (8) Inefficiency and incompetence in the performance of official duties; (9) Receiving for personal use of a fees; gift or other valuable thing in the course of official duties or in connection therewith when such fees, gift, or other valuable thing is given by any person in the hope or expectation of receiving a favor or better treatment than that accorded other persons, or committing acts punishable under the anti-graft laws; (10) Conviction of a crime involving moral turpitude; (11) Improper or unauthorized solicitation of contributions from subordinate employees and by teachers or school officials from school children; (12) Violation of existing Civil Service Law and rules or reasonable office regulations; (13) Falsification of official document; (14) Frequent unauthorized absences or tardiness in reporting for duty, loafing or frequent unauthorized absences from duty during regular office hours; (15) Habitual drunkenness; (16) Gambling prohibited by law; (17) Refusal to perform official duty or render overtime service; (18) Disgraceful, immoral or dishonest conduct prior to entering the service; (19) Physical or mental incapacity or disability due to immoral or vicious habits; (20) Borrowing money by superior officers from subordinates or lending by subordinates to superior officers; (22) Lending money at usurious rates of interest; (22) Willful failure to pay just debts or willful failure to pay taxes due to the government; (23) Contracting loans of money or other property from persons with whom the office of the employee concerned has business relations; (24) Pursuit of private business, vocation or profession without the permission required by Civil Service rules and regulations; (25) Insubordination; (26) Engaging directly or indirectly in partisan political activities by one holding non-political office; (27) Conduct prejudicial to the best interest of the service; (28) Lobbying for personal interest or gain in legislative halls and offices without authority; (29) Promoting the sale of tickets in behalf of private enterprises that are not intended for charitable or public welfare purposes and even in the latter cases where there is no prior authority; and (30) Nepotism as defined in Section 49 of this Decree. On the other hand, private school personnel may be terminated from the service on the following just causes: (1) serious misconduct; (2) willful disobedience; (3) gross and habitual neglect of duties; (4) willful breach of trust; (5) theft; (6) abandonment; (7) closing or cessation of operation; (8) introduction of labor-saving devices; (9) redundancy; (10) retrenchment; and (11) disease. Other instances of termination or dismissal are: (1) violation of company regulations; (2) conviction of crime; (3) immorality; (4) illegal strike; (5) physical disability; (6) prolonged absence. Moreover, the Labor Code of the Philippines, mandated the following as just causes for dismissal: (1) by the employer, because the employee commits a wrongful act; (2) by the employee, because the employer is at fault or commits a wrongful act against the person of the employee; (3) due to business reverses such as retrenchment, closure of the business, etc.; and, (4) due to disease contracted by a worker. 4. Process of Dismissal of School Personnel Public school personnel may avail of two types of procedure, either formal or non-summary procedure or summary procedure. The formal or non-summary procedure consists of the following steps: (1) Filing of the complaint by a superior of the teacher, or the filing of an open and written complaint by any other person; (2) Notification of the respondent in writing of the charges against him/her; (3) Written response of the respondent to the charges against him or her within 72 hours after receipt of complaint; (4) Conduct of an investigation into the charges of the complaint and respondent's answer; (5) Decision of the case; (6) Appeal in case of unfavorable decision; and, (7) Decision or appeal.
520 ## - SUMMARY, ETC.
Summary, etc. In the summary procedure, according to Section 40 of the Civil Service Law: No formal investigation is necessary and the respondent may be immediately removed or dismissed if any of the following circumstances are present: (a) When the charge is serious and evidence of guilt is strong; (b) When the respondent is a recidivist or has been repeatedly charged and there is a reasonable ground to believe that he is guilty of the present charge; and (c) When the teacher is notoriously undesirable. The Magna Carta guarantees safeguard at each stage of any disciplinary procedure such that the teacher shall have: (1) the right to be informed of the charges in writing, (2) the right to full access to the evidence on the case; (3) the right to defend himself and to be defended by a representative of his choice and/or by his organization, adequate time being given to the teacher for the preparation of his defense; and (4) the right to appeal to clearly designated authorities. No publicity should be given to any disciplinary action being taken against a teacher during the pendency of his case. Section 9 of the Magna Carta for Public School Teachers mandated that administrative charges against a teacher shall be heard initially by a committee composed of the corresponding School Superintendent of the division or a duly authorized representative, who should at least have a rank of a division supervisor where the teacher belongs, a chairman, a representative of the local or in its absence, any existing provincial or national teacher's organization, and supervisor of the division, the last two to b
Uniform Resource Identifier <a href=""></a>
521 ## - TARGET AUDIENCE NOTE
Target audience note
--
Source
533 ## - REPRODUCTION NOTE
Physical description of reproduction
--
Type of reproduction
Date of reproduction
Place of reproduction
Note about reproduction
Agency responsible for reproduction
540 ## - TERMS GOVERNING USE AND REPRODUCTION NOTE
Authorization
--
Terms governing use and reproduction 5
542 ## - INFORMATION RELATING TO COPYRIGHT STATUS
Copyright date
--
Copyright statement
546 ## - LANGUAGE NOTE
Language note
--
Information code or alphabet
583 ## - ACTION NOTE
Institution to which field applies
--
Action agent
Time/date of action
Action
Action identification
590 ## - LOCAL NOTE (RLIN)
Local note
--
Provenance (VM) [OBSOLETE]
600 ## - SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--PERSONAL NAME
Numeration
--
Form subdivision
Title of a work
Titles and other words associated with a name 2
Fuller form of name
Personal name
General subdivision 0
Geographic subdivision
Dates associated with a name
Chronological subdivision
610 ## - SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--CORPORATE NAME
Subordinate unit
--
Form subdivision
Title of a work 2
General subdivision
Corporate name or jurisdiction name as entry element
Form subheading 0
Name of part/section of a work
Geographic subdivision
Date of meeting or treaty signing 6
Chronological subdivision
611 ## - SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--MEETING NAME
Meeting name or jurisdiction name as entry element
--
Date of meeting or treaty signing
Number of part/section/meeting 2
Location of meeting 0
Form subdivision
630 ## - SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--UNIFORM TITLE
General subdivision
--
Uniform title
Date of treaty signing
Name of part/section of a work 20
Form subdivision
648 ## - SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--CHRONOLOGICAL TERM
Source of heading or term
--
Chronological term
650 ## - SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--TOPICAL TERM
General subdivision
--
Topical term or geographic name entry element
Active dates
Topical term following geographic name entry element
Geographic subdivision
Chronological subdivision 20
Form subdivision
651 ## - SUBJECT ADDED ENTRY--GEOGRAPHIC NAME
General subdivision
--
Geographic name
Chronological subdivision 20
Form subdivision
Geographic subdivision
655 ## - INDEX TERM--GENRE/FORM
Authority record control number or standard number
--
Genre/form data or focus term
Chronological subdivision 2
Geographic subdivision
700 ## - ADDED ENTRY--PERSONAL NAME
Relationship information
--
Title of a work
Titles and other words associated with a name
Numeration
Version 1
Fuller form of name
Date of a work
Form subheading 40
Name of part/section of a work
Dates associated with a name
Relator term
Personal name
Language of a work
Number of part/section of a work 6
710 ## - ADDED ENTRY--CORPORATE NAME
Subordinate unit
--
Title of a work
Location of meeting
Relator term
Date of a work
Form subheading 40
Name of part/section of a work
Date of meeting or treaty signing 5
Language of a work
Number of part/section/meeting 6
Corporate name or jurisdiction name as entry element
711 ## - ADDED ENTRY--MEETING NAME
Meeting name or jurisdiction name as entry element
--
Date of meeting or treaty signing
Number (BK CF MP MU SE VM MX) [OBSOLETE]
Number of part/section/meeting
Title of a work
Location of meeting
730 ## - ADDED ENTRY--UNIFORM TITLE
Version
--
Uniform title
Date of treaty signing
Number of part/section of a work
Name of part/section of a work
Date of a work
Language of a work
Form subheading
740 ## - ADDED ENTRY--UNCONTROLLED RELATED/ANALYTICAL TITLE
--
--
Uncontrolled related/analytical title
--
--
Number of part/section of a work
-- 6
753 ## - SYSTEM DETAILS ACCESS TO COMPUTER FILES
Operating system
--
Make and model of machine
767 ## - TRANSLATION ENTRY
Title
--
Record control number
770 ## - SUPPLEMENT/SPECIAL ISSUE ENTRY
Title
--
Record control number
International Standard Serial Number
773 ## - HOST ITEM ENTRY
Main entry heading
--
Place, publisher, and date of publication
Related parts
Material-specific details
Title
Edition
--
Relationship information
Abbreviated title
775 ## - OTHER EDITION ENTRY
Title
--
Record control number
International Standard Serial Number
776 ## - ADDITIONAL PHYSICAL FORM ENTRY
Uniform title
--
Main entry heading
Place, publisher, and date of publication
Edition
International Standard Book Number
Relationship information
Title
International Standard Serial Number
Physical description
Qualifying information
Record control number
780 ## - PRECEDING ENTRY
International Standard Serial Number
--
Main entry heading
Related parts
Title
Record control number
785 ## - SUCCEEDING ENTRY
Title
--
Record control number
Main entry heading
International Standard Serial Number
787 ## - OTHER RELATIONSHIP ENTRY
International Standard Serial Number
--
Place, publisher, and date of publication
Related parts
Relationship information
Title
Record control number
800 ## - SERIES ADDED ENTRY--PERSONAL NAME
Personal name
--
Dates associated with a name
Language of a work
Date of a work
Title of a work 0
Fuller form of name
Volume/sequential designation
810 ## - SERIES ADDED ENTRY--CORPORATE NAME
Corporate name or jurisdiction name as entry element
--
Subordinate unit
Date of a work
Title of a work
--
Volume/sequential designation
830 ## - SERIES ADDED ENTRY--UNIFORM TITLE
International Standard Serial Number
--
Uniform title
Name of part/section of a work
Number of part/section of a work
Language of a work 0
Volume/sequential designation
942 ## - ADDED ENTRY ELEMENTS
Institution code [OBSOLETE]
-- lcc
Item type Book
Holdings
Withdrawn status Lost status Source of classification or shelving scheme Damaged status Not for loan Collection code Permanent Location Current Location Shelving location Date acquired Fund Source Total Checkouts Full call number Barcode Date last seen Price effective from Item type
          Graduate School-Thesis/Dissert PLM PLM Graduate School Library 2025-09-20     LB 2805 .S26 1987 G20 2025-09-20 2025-09-20 Book

© Copyright 2024 Phoenix Library Management System - Pinnacle Technologies, Inc. All Rights Reserved.